Best Etsy Alternatives for Handmade Sellers (2026)

According to Etsy's Q3 2025 report, there are currently 5.5 million active sellers—meaning roughly 670,000 have left the platform in the past year.

But where should you go after Etsy? Are there sites like Etsy where you can sell your products and earn even more?

In this guide, we’re listing 11 Etsy alternatives for anyone ready to switch and find a new home for their shop.

At a Glance: Top Etsy Alternatives for Sellers (2026)

If you need to decide fast, here is a summary of the top Etsy alternatives and what makes them better or more profitable than Etsy.

1. Amazon Handmade

Amazon Handmade is the heavy hitter in the world of Etsy alternatives. It lives within the massive Amazon ecosystem but is restricted to verified artisans, ensuring your handcrafted work isn't sitting next to mass-produced plastic.

• Price: A flat 15% referral fee. While high, Amazon waives the $39.99/mo professional fee for approved artisans.
• The Vibe: Professional, fast-paced, and massive.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Unlike Etsy, which requires you to master SEO to be found among millions of small shops, Amazon Handmade puts you in front of people who are already there to buy now.

With FBA (Fulfillment by Amazon), you can offer Prime shipping, which is something Etsy simply can't match.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Sellers with "giftable" products who have the inventory to handle high volume and want to stop worrying about shipping logistics.

2. eBay

eBay has shed its "online garage sale" image to become a legitimate Etsy alternative for unique handmade goods. With 159 million active buyers, it offers a scale that few other platforms can provide.

• Price: eBay's fees for crafts are roughly 12.7% on the total sale up to $2,500, plus a $0.30 per-order fee.
• The Vibe: A universal marketplace where "unique" is the main selling point.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

eBay’s global reach and auction format give you flexibility Etsy doesn't. If you have a one-of-a-kind piece and aren't sure how to price it, an eBay auction can often drive the price higher than a fixed Etsy listing ever would.

Plus, their international shipping program is significantly more robust.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Artists selling high-ticket, one-of-a-kind items or those who want to tap into an international market without the shipping headache.

Image: Appshunter

3. Facebook Marketplace

If you're looking for a low-barrier Etsy alternative, Facebook Marketplace is the most accessible choice. It’s no longer just for old sofas; it’s a thriving hub for local artisans.

• Price: 100% free for local pickup. Shipped items have a low 5% fee.
• The Vibe: Friendly, local, and direct.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Etsy's shipping costs can kill the profit on heavy items like custom wood furniture or large pottery. Facebook Marketplace eliminates that by focusing on local meetups.

There are no listing fees and no waiting for an algorithm to "warm up"—you can post and sell on the same day.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Beginners testing the waters or creators making bulky items that are a nightmare to ship.

Image: BoliviaInteligente

4. Goimagine

Goimagine is often called the "Old Etsy." It is a dedicated Etsy alternative that focuses on social good, donating its profits to children’s charities while maintaining a strictly handmade marketplace.

• Price: Starts with a free plan for 12 listings; paid plans are $15/mo with 2% transaction fees.
• The Vibe: Ethical, community-driven, and "purely" handmade.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Etsy has faced criticism for allowing mass-produced items to flood the site. Goimagine has a strict verification process to ensure everything is actually handmade.

If you’re tired of competing with "handmade" items that are actually drop-shipped from factories, this is your sanctuary.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Purist makers who want a marketplace that aligns with their values and offers a more intimate community.

5. Artisans Cooperative

Born from the 2022 Etsy seller strikes, this is the most radical Etsy alternative. It’s a seller-owned marketplace where the people making the goods actually own the platform.

• Price: $100 one-time membership buy-in; 3% transaction fee.
• The Vibe: Cooperative, transparent, and artist-centric.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

On Etsy, you are a user of a service owned by shareholders. At the Artisans Cooperative, you are a co-owner.

You get a vote in policy changes and a share of the profits. It’s the ultimate "power to the people" platform.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Sellers who are fed up with corporate policy shifts and want a permanent, stable home where they have a seat at the table.

6. IndieMade

IndieMade is a unique Etsy alternative because it’s not a marketplace—it’s a site builder designed specifically for artists who want to bridge the gap between Etsy and a standalone store.

• Price: IndieMade pricing ranges from $4.95 to $19.95 per month.
• The Vibe: Independent but easy to manage.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

IndieMade offers a "best of both worlds" approach. It features an incredible Etsy integration that lets you sync your listings.

You can keep your Etsy shop for traffic but use IndieMade as your "professional" home where you pay zero commission and own the customer relationship.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Sellers ready to build their own brand identity but who find platforms like Shopify too complex or expensive.

7. Big Cartel

Big Cartel is the "cool kid" of Etsy alternatives. It’s tailored specifically for artists, musicians, and designers who want a minimalist, boutique feel.

• Price: Free plan for 5 products. Paid plans start at $9.99/mo with no transaction fees.
• The Vibe: Artistic, clean, and minimalist.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Etsy’s layout is cluttered and standardized. Big Cartel gives you a dedicated space where your work isn't surrounded by "similar items" from your competitors. It’s perfect for creators with a strong visual brand who want their store to look like a high-end gallery.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Illustrators, jewelry designers, and apparel makers with a loyal social media following.

8. Folksy (UK)

Folksy is the UK’s answer to Etsy. It’s a regional Etsy alternative that focuses strictly on British craft and heritage.

• Price: £0.15 per listing + 6% transaction fee.
• The Vibe: Local, supportive, and very British.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Folksy doesn't charge commission on shipping—only on the product price. For UK sellers, this is a massive win compared to Etsy’s fee structure. Plus, because it's UK-only, you aren't competing with global mass-production; you are competing with your neighbors in a much friendlier environment.

Who would love this more than Etsy? UK-based makers who want to support the local "Made in Britain" movement and value human customer support over bots.

Image: Folksy

9. Cratejoy

Cratejoy is a specialized Etsy alternative that shifts the focus from one-off sales to monthly subscriptions. It’s the king of the "box" economy.

• Price: Monthly fees start at $24.99 plus category-based referral fees.
• The Vibe: Curated, recurring, and kit-based.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

On Etsy, you have to find a new customer for every single sale. On Cratejoy, you find a customer once, and they pay you every month. For makers who can curate kits (like DIY soap kits), this creates a level of financial stability Etsy simply can’t offer.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Creators who have a "consumable" product or a series of items that work well as a monthly subscription.

10. Mercari

Mercari is a fast-paced Etsy alternative that works like a hybrid between a marketplace and a social app. It’s incredibly popular for quick sales and "destashing."

• Price: A simple, flat 10% seller fee.
• The Vibe: Casual, fast, and interactive.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

Etsy is a slow burn—it takes time to build a shop's reputation. Mercari is "fast commerce." The "make an offer" button encourages interaction and moves inventory quickly. It's the perfect place to sell your overstock or supplies that aren't moving on Etsy.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Sellers who want to list items in seconds from their phone and don't mind a bit of "haggling" to get a sale.

11. Shopify

Shopify is the final destination for most successful Etsy sellers. It is the ultimate Etsy alternative because it gives you total ownership of your business.

• Price: Starts at ~$29/mo plus processing fees. No transaction fees with Shopify Payments.
• The Vibe: Professional, scalable, and independent.

Why it’s a better Etsy alternative:

On Etsy, you "rent" a space. On Shopify, you "own" the building. You get the email addresses of every customer (crucial for marketing), you control the entire design, and as you grow, the fixed monthly cost becomes much cheaper than Etsy’s percentage-based fees.

Who would love this more than Etsy? Established sellers with a following who want to stop paying "rent" to a marketplace and start building a real brand empire.

FAQs

Who is Etsy’s biggest competitor?

Amazon Handmade is usually the closest in scale and traffic to Etsy. Other sites like eBay, Facebook Marketplace, Goimagine, and Folksy also compete, each in their own way.

Why are so many sellers leaving Etsy?

Mainly because costs keep going up and competition is getting crowded. On top of that, some sellers see sudden traffic drops without a clear reason, prompting them to diversify into other Etsy alternatives.